The title to this piece is ‘ Vuvuzelas, what’s the problem’ which seems a funny title when you start to type it out but conveys the idea and purpose of this article in a non-threatening way quite well. There has been some discussion about Vuvzelas, and when I say some, I mean a lot, Loads, it hasn’t stopped. The vuvuzela is a loud horn that in the last ten years has become popular in South Africa and has put a very effective end to the native singing that was previously much beloved around the soccer grounds of South Africa.So the Vuvuzela is a cultural artefact of South Africa, it may drown out all other fan’s voices but what is the problem with it? Are those complainants who despair at its B flat drone, somehow aging racists who are hating the heritage of this African country?
Well, it seems to me the answer is blissfully simple. If you watch the Netherlands playing what do you expect to hear? Is it the traditional Dutch supporters band? If you watch South Korea what are you expecting from the sound? Perhaps the traditional drumming that dominated South Koreas games as host at the last World Cup?
If you see Brazil playing football on the television do you expect to hear that familiar Samba beat? Perhaps as an England fan you would like to hear the singing of England fans just to know they are there? Even with the USA you know the dull chants that will accompany the game.
So what is the thing standing in the way of the fabulous cultural diversity of the World Cup? The reason that you will never know just from listening which of the diverse nations of the world is playing? The thing preventing the spreading of understanding of national identity throughout Africa? Yes, it’s the vuvuzela.
Some of the more simplistic on the left have sought to characterise the dislike of the vuvuzela as some kind of racism. Others have talked of the oppression of ‘Cultural diversity’. Surely the vuvuzela is a thing for the games of those African nations that employ it, and in the other games we should embrace the cultural identity of those countrys playing in the match. To not do so would make us all seem like fascists surely?
The real key to all this is to just remember the name of the competition, it’s the World Cup, not South Africa’s Cup, the World Cup. So come on South Africa let us hear the sounds of the world, it’s why we are all here after all.
